American Idol Season 4, Week 16: Songs by Jerry Leiber & Mike Stoller / top 40 songs

Everybody had to sing twice this week. The first song had to be something written by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, the second song had to be from this week's top 40 list.

Here's a full playlist:

1. Anthony - Poison Ivy by The Coasters / Incomplete by Backstreet Boys
   
2. Scott - On Broadway by George Benson / Every Time You Go Away by Brian McKnight
   
3. Vonzell - Treat Me Nice by Elvis Presley / When You Tell Me by Season 4 American Idol contestants
   
4. Bo - Stand By Me by Ben E. King / Heaven by Los Lonely Boys
   
5. Carrie - Trouble by Elvis / Bless the Broken Road by Rascal Flatts

Vonzell was the best as usual, even though Simon trash talked her. She looked absolutely stunning for her second song.

Anthony was just awful for both songs, couldn't even keep track of the camera. He needs to go.

We're voting for Vonzell, Bo, and Carrie.